Lisa Blades, the couple's wedding planner (and Lebenzon's aunt) told People magazine, "The wedding was spectacular…With Ana's work load and the success and craziness that come with a hit TV show, I think that Noah has been a great stabilizing force in her life. Committing to each other in marriage is calming for both of them."

The ceremony took place before 85 guests on the veranda of the Horned Dorset Primavera Hotel in Rincón, Puerto Rico. Ortiz wore Monique Lhuillier and Lebenzon wore Prada. "Ugly Betty" cast members America Ferrera, Ashley Jensen (who plays Christina) and Mark Indelicato (who plays Hilda's son Justin) were present.