According to a source for the Daily Mail, Jude has "always had a soft spot for Natalie," who he has also worked with in Closer and Cold Mountain. "Jude thinks she's beautiful and they get along very well," says the tattler.

Law decided to make his move on Portman at the My Blueberry Nights wrap party recently. Says the snitch, "Natalie is not with her on-off boyfriend Gael Garcia Bernal at the moment, so she saw no harm in having some fun with Jude at the party." This pair's fun included leaving the celebration together at 2 am after chatting in a private booth for several hours. Wait until Lindsay hears about this.