Joy, in particular, is not able to handle Elisabeth’s outspoken Republican politics. An insider told the National Enquirer, "Joy thinks Elisabeth's a phony. She says it makes her sick to watch Elisabeth get on her soapbox. Joy makes fun of her behind her back, sticking her finger down her throat like she's retching!" Another source close to Behar claims she said, "Barbara likes [Elizabeth], but if it was up to me, I'd vote her off 'The View.'"

Elisabeth is not oblivious to the stress her beliefs have been stirring up. A spy on the show told the New York Daily News that since Rosie has joined the cast, "[Elisabeth] is crying every day. No one can control Rosie, and Elisabeth can't contain her feelings. She gets so upset all the time."

O’Donnell’s rep denied the claims that there is bad blood between her client and Hasselbeck, stating, "Elisabeth was at Rosie's house this weekend with her daughter, Grace. They might not agree on politics, but that's what makes the show great. Ratings are up 59%."