According to a source for Page Six, at the party, which took place at the Polaroid Beach House in Malibu, "Paris was hanging out with Brandon Davis, her sister Nicky and Bijou Phillips. She made it a point to whisper and laugh very loudly the entire time, snickering behind Lindsay's back."

A witness told Star magazine, "At first, everyone thought it would be okay because [Paris and Lindsay have] run into each other out at clubs. But all of a sudden, a tearful Lindsay ran to a back bedroom and wouldn't come out because Paris was there…She basically hid out there. Her boyfriend, Harry Morton, was there, comforting her.�?

By the time Lindsay emerged - in a new outfit - half and hour had passed. She had decided, apparently, to try and be the bigger person and ignore Paris’s teasing. Page Six claims that Harry’s pals weren’t about to let Paris’s juvenile behavior slide. At one point, “one of Morton's friends jumped up and faked a kick to her bony backside when she wasn't looking,�? the gossip column reported.

But even the kick wasn’t enough to raise Lindsay’s spirits. The final straw for Lohan was when the DJ starting playing Paris’s CD. When that happened, another Star insider said, "She left. And she was pissed-off."