A source for Page Six detailed the conditions at the club that night: "There were only like six tables." When Lohan got up from her coveted spot to trail Hilton to the bathroom for what one New York Daily News source claimed was “a huge fight," Diddy’s entourage took over Lindsay’s table. Upon her return, Lindsay jokingly asked Diddy what he was doing at her table, only "he didn't realize she was joking," said another NYDN witness. "He then yelled at her and told her to get out," claims the source.

Another source for the Daily News claimed the entertainer formerly known as Puff Daddy "was really mean to [Lindsay]." A spy for Page Six said, “His bodyguards came over and picked Lindsay up to get her out." A source close to Diddy confirmed: "Lindsay was being so loud and obnoxious. [Diddy’s] security became concerned and came over to escort her away."

Of course, nobody keeps Lindsay away from a party. Furious, the redhead complained to her pals, Scott Sartiano and Richie Akiva, the club’s owners. She insisted that Diddy should be kicked out of Butter for his behavior. Lindsay lost out on this fight, though, and moved on to Aer, where her battle with Paris continued.