"I guess she was jealous that her new guy is spending time with someone who is being mean to her," a source told Perez. Thus, Lindsay’s friends all decided to head over to Jessica’s table to lure Brett away. Eventually, Lindsay’s friends got to Pastor who called Lindsay a bitch. Lindsay then confronted Pastor and said, "Do you not like me because I work with Rachel Zoe and not you?" Pastor replied, "No, honey, you're doing just fine without me."

Perez’s account of the incident refutes Us Weekly’s current cover story, which claims that the battle was between Lohan and Simpson. Us says Simpson broke down in tears after Lohan said, “What’s the matter? When your sister is around, you can talk shit about me, but now that Ashlee’s not here, what are you going to do? C’mon! I’m 19 and you’re 25. Say something, you coward!…You are the most insecure little girl! Fuck it!'"